The Stuttgart Philharmonic is regarded as one of Germany’s finest orchestras, having a total strength of eighty-eight musicians of which around fifty played at Bridgewater Hall this evening in Manchester. The Germanic musical heritage is a key element of this orchestra’s reputation, regularly putting on Beethoven and Richard Strauss days in a programme that extends to over 100 events each year so perhaps it was no surprise that tonight’s concert was comprised entirely of music from the German-speaking world with works by Mendelssohn, Mozart and Brahms.
The evening started with the atmospheric crowd pleaser, ‘The Hebridean Overture’ more generally referred to as ‘Fingal’s Cave’. This famous piece needs little description, starting with a haunting mood and building to a grand climax that fully evokes the majesty of the seas and landscape of the Hebridean islands. An appropriate introduction for a visiting German orchestra of a powerful work by German composer that was inspired by a visit to the U.K.
For the next offering, a grand piano was wheeled on stage for piano soloist Alim Beisembayev, a native of Kazakhstan and winner of the 2021 Leeds International Piano competition. After the intensity and emotion of the first piece, Mozart’s Piano Concerto No 20 seemed a rather bland follow-on, written in three movements, of which the first two never seemed to build to any kind of climax with the third movement sounding rather jolly by comparison and jarring somewhat as a result to what preceded it. This is naturally a very personal opinion but it was certainly hard to discern any memorable melodies or clear direction in this piece which can hardly be considered one of Mozart’s most essential works, in contrast for example to the more well-known Concerto No 21.
For the second half, the orchestra increased in strength from around forty to over fifty and lively Argentinean conductor Mariano Chiacchiarini went into full flow as The Stuttgart Philharmonic delivered a stirring performance of Brahms’ Symphony No.3 in F major. This is a remarkable piece of music which is hard to describe for a number of reasons. The mood lacks the sense of urgency or the dramatic style of say many Russian composers whilst holding the listener with a feeling that the music is taking you somewhere; akin in some ways to works by Beethoven but without the sense of heaviness. More particularly, for the most part, the whole orchestra sounded like a complete unit as opposed to many works which give specific turns for various sections of the orchestra to shine individually. It was not hard to see why musicologist Carl Dahlhause has described a Brahms symphony as written for the individual listener rather than the bourgeois public. This is the kind of music that invites the listener to take out for themselves the meanings of what they hear as opposed to listening to a story being told; the kind of music you can lose yourself in. Certainly not your typical symphony and recommended to anyone looking to broaden their appreciation of classical music.
The night closed with a bonus offering of two of Brahms’ lively Hungarian dances and the audience was certainly well satisfied. There was plenty of passion and drama across the pieces and the inclusion of Mozart’s Concerto No 20 certainly created variety if perhaps this choice was much more a matter of personal taste than either what preceded it or followed. Ultimately though, the concert was a celebration of Brahms and what must be one of his most enigmatic works.
An interestingly well-themed evening of Germanic composers and musicians, with a little Latin inspiration thrown in from conductor Mariano Chiacchiarini. The Stuttgart Philharmonic has a deservedly high reputation.
https://www.bridgewater-hall.co.uk/
Reviewer: John Waterhouse
On: 20.11.26

No comments:
Post a Comment