This touring production based on the novel by James M. Cain, is directed by Oscar Toeman by special arrangement of ILP Theatrical, adapted for the stage by Tom Holloway and is presented at the Playhouse, the sister theatre to the Everyman. It is a stylish venue, just a few minutes’ walk from Liverpool Lime Street station and very close to Queen Square bus station. Thank you to the staff for their welcome and assistance. Unfortunately, there was no programme for this show, but I was given a printed sheet of paper listing the cast. The drama is set in 1930s Los Angeles against the backdrop of the Great Depression.
When my friend and I sat down, we were greeted by an empty stage, intriguingly designed by Ti Green, which had industrial style panelling on either side. We found out later that there were doors built into the panels that allowed entry and exit from the performance space. The action started when insurance salesman Walter Huff (Ciarán Owens), dressed in a cream suit, confidently strode onto stage and immediately broke the ‘fourth wall’ by directly addressing the audience. This wasn’t narration; instead, he was inviting us into this Hollywood noir, posing the question: “If no one was watching, how far would you go to get what you want?” Huff set the scene, outlining his plans for, and his role in, the ‘perfect murder’. We were quickly introduced to the intended victim Mr Nirdlinger (Oliver Ryan) and his glamorous second wife Phyllis (Mischa Barton). Nirdlinger’s first wife, whom Phyllis had been nurse to, had died in tragic circumstances, and Phyllis is now stepmother to teenager Lola (Sophia Roberts). Although Lola is undoubtedly spoilt by her rich parents, she yearns for a life of her own. She gets involved with moody Nino Zachetti (Joseph Langdon), who is very much the strong and silent type!
Huff is a chancer, always on the lookout for a deal to keep his bosses happy and earn him good commission. When he visits the Nirdlingers to discuss the renewal of their car insurance policy, he overcomes the reticence shown by the husband towards any salesmen. Huff is unsurprisingly instantly attracted to Phyllis, whom he senses is extremely unhappy. Armed with the knowledge of Phyllis’s situation, he uses all of his nous and experience to sell a new policy with a ‘double indemnity’ accident clause which Phyllis’s husband is blissfully unaware of. In other words, the policy will actually pay out twice as much should the husband die in specific circumstances. Huff and femme fatale Phyllis are attracted to one another, hatch the deadly plot and begin an affair, but you are left with the impression that both participants are playing each other in a dangerous game.
Once the new policies have been signed, the action switches to the insurance company’s office where we meet Huff’s wily, gruff and world-weary boss Barton Keyes (Martin Marquez). Keyes makes no attempt to hide his disdain and contempt towards young whippersnapper Norton (also played by Joseph Langdon) who has now taken over the company. Huff has a methodical and hard-working secretary Nettie (enthusiastically portrayed by Gillian Saker).
I will not say anything more about the plot itself so as not to spoil it for the reader, but I can highly recommend this production. As the fast-paced episodic action continued, the reason the stage was empty at the beginning became clear, with rapid changes of scene being required, switching between the Nurdlinger’s house and car, the insurance company’s office and downtown LA. The ensemble of Ms Saker, Simon Victor, Estelle Cousins and Patrick Fleming gave character and context to the outdoor scenes and acted as stage hands to facilitate the smooth transitions. Sound cues designed and composed by Dan Balfour and Zac Gvi, along with lighting delivered by Josh Gadsby, effectively added to the moodiness and tension throughout.
The production runs until Saturday 18th, including matinees on Thursday and Saturday. More information on the play, cast and crew can be found at its official website: https://www.doubleindemnityplay.co.uk/
Tickets can be purchased in person at the box office, by phone on 0151 709 4776 or via the theatre’s website: https://everymanplayhouse.com/
Reviewer - David Swift
On -15/04/2026












