Friday, 27 January 2023

OPERA REVIEW: Madama Butterfly - The Opera House, Manchester.


The Ukrainian National Opera returns to Manchester again with Ellen Kent’s lavish production of Puccini’s classic, ‘Madama Butterfly’ to start off three nights of equally lavish productions at the Opera House, as well as the 2023 season! The perfect beginning which saw a full house, and a very receptive audience.

Puccini’s tragic love story set in turn of the century Japan, near Nagasaki, tells the story of one Japanese woman’s devotion to her American husband and the eventual fall out which follows. Cio-Cio San, the titular Madama Butterfly (performed by the exquisite soprano, Elena Dee) a young and impressionable girl is married to the brash and immature American naval officer, Benjamin Franklin Pinkerton (tenor, Vitalii Liskovetskyi). Abandoned by Pinkerton, whose career in the Navy takes him away from Japan, and growing maturity makes him realise the impossibility of the situation, Cio-Cio San raises their child, Sorrow, with the help of her maid, Suzuki (mezzo-soprano, Natalia Mateeva) in the vain hope that Pinkerton’s ship will arrive back in Nagasaki bay. When the Abraham Lincoln finally does drop anchor, it is revealed that Pinkerton is now married to an American woman and wishes to take their child. In an attempt to shield the still fragile Cio-Cio San from the truth, Suzuki and the American consul, Sharpless (baritone, Olexandr Forkushak) try to delicately approach the situation, however it is to no avail, and with devastating consequences.

The story is simple in its premise, however its satirical undertones in the perception of the growing power of the United States, combined with the music and performance, make ‘Madama Butterfly’ a far more intricate and interesting story that one may first realise. This work may be Puccini’s most delicate and heartfelt; it may be his crowning achievement. Even if one is not familiar with opera or the music of Puccini, ‘The Humming Chorus’ which transitions the last act from night to day, will be familiar to you. A beautifully innocent and pure piece, which really makes great use of the lack of sung dialogue and captures the emotion and tone of the entire show. ‘Un Bel Di Vendremo’ is the other standout piece, and the glistening jewel that sits atop the encrusted crown that is ‘Madama Butterfly’. Beautifully performed by Dee, the song captures the heartbreak of our main character and is a great display of vocal prowess and emotional performance.

The set design and costumes really add to the overall genuine feel of the opera. Ellen Kent has a keen eye for detail and a dedication to presenting ‘Madama Butterfly’ as in intended when it first premiered over one hundred years ago. It is this eye and dedication, which makes these productions some of most luxurious and eye catching there are. To put it simply, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it! It is a problem which splits people down the middle, you have the traditionalists who like things to be presented in the way which they were intended, and then the modernist-mixer-uppers (to phrase it elegantly) who have to tweak things here and there, changing the settings and periods in an attempt to alter the underlying themes or messages. The traditional presentation is what makes the opera this grand spectacle that you look forward to seeing and leave, counting down the days until you can see your next one. It’s one of the many things this production gets right. Many will read this either nodding or shaking their heads.

‘Madama Butterfly’ has of course influenced many remakes, adaptations so on and so forth. The hit musical ‘Miss Saigon’ is probably the most successful of these, however it cannot come close to what ‘Butterfly’ offers. The audience experiences a vast range of emotions from humour to sorrow and pain, with a particular plot point warranting a very audible gasp from the crowd being a memorable moment.

To not compare too much to last year, but the best was saved for last when this was performed on the last night, following two other very good shows. It begs the question, how great must this run of shows be if they’re starting off with ‘Madama Butterfly’? The performance certainly sets the bar incredibly high.

Ellen Kent has worked wonders to get the entire Ukrainian Opera and Ballet Theatre (based in Kyiv) through warzones and across the continent to the United Kingdom. Her efforts must be commended as well as the stellar work by the theatre itself so far from a war torn home. The respect and love was mutual as the crowd stood for ‘Schne Ne Vmerla Ukrainy I Slava, I Volia’, the Ukrainian national anthem, followed by rapturous applause towards the gesture, the cast and crew with the biggest cheer saved for Madame Butterfly herself, Elena Dee. Whose performance captivated the entire opera house and gave us all goose bumps.

Puccini’s ‘La Boheme’ and Verdi’s ‘Aida’ will follow on the 27th and 28th respectfully. The audience tonight showed that ‘Madama Butterfly’ can still command an audience, signifying its reputation in the 21st Century. Furthermore it also shows that the people of Greater Manchester love this highbrow, cultured art form. The troupe will be touring all around the country and Ireland between now and summer.

Reviewer - Daryl Griffin
on - 26.1.23


No comments:

Post a Comment