Sunday, 23 February 2025

OPERA REVIEW ELLEN KENT'S LA BOHEME MANCHESTER OPERA HOUSE

Manchester Opera House seemed to be bustling last night as crowds gathered and flocked to take

their seats in anticipation for Ellen Kent’s production of Giacomo Puccini’s 1896 classic, La Bohème,

featuring the talented voices of the Ukranian Opera and Ballet Theatre. Whenever Kent brings the

opera to Manchester, one cannot help but feel that an old friend has come to visit, with the mixture

of music, wonderful and lavish sets as well as the tear inducing performances being like a warm and

assuring embrace. La Bohème returns after being last performed by the Ukranian Opera in 2023, and

somehow Ellen Kent has taken what seemed like a winning formula two years ago and improved

upon it, making this season’s production of the tragedy one of the best operas so far, rivalled only by

her production of Bizet’s Carmen last year.

What made this production of La Bohème so good was the superb casting. Tenor, Davit Sumbadze as

Rodolfo, brought an air of innocence as well as a mischievous immaturity which blended well with

the young poet’s friends Marcello (Iurie Gisca), Schaunard (Vitalii Cebotari) and Colline (Valeriu

Cojocaru); however this was most noticeable against Soprano, Elana Dee’s Mimi as the two shared a

chemistry which elevated their romance beyond a level which was perhaps lacking in the ’23

production. Their romance speaks volumes even before the end of the first act, and as such really

hits hard when tragedy strikes in fourth act.

Set in 1830s Paris, La Bohème is a tragedy (albeit with its fair share of comedy) following four

Bohemians as they struggle creatively to make ends meet as well as romantically. On Christmas Eve

after seeing off their landlord, Rodolfo meets Mimi and the two fall for each other (featuring the

opera’s best known aria “Che Gelida Manina” which the motif recurs throughout the story). When

the two lovebirds join Rodolfo’s friends for food and drink, Marcello’s old flame, Musetta, appears,

thus juxtaposing Rodolfo and Mimi’s more serious romance with the more volatile yet lighthearted

romance. A few months later, a clearly ill Mimi confides in Marcello about her faltering relationship

with Rodolfo, all the while Marcello and Musetta’s rocky relationship start to break down once

more. In the final act, set in the burgeoning spring, we see a return to the situation presented in the

first act. Rodolfo and Marcello are alone, and Schaunard and Colline do what they can to bring in

provisions, when Musetta appears having found Mimi dying on the street. After rekindling their

romance, Mimi dies although Rodolfo is initially unaware, he breaks down upon finding out.

The story is an incredibly simple yet effective one. One of the many reasons why La Bohème works

as an entry level opera. Despite being set almost two hundred years ago, Rodolfo and the other

Bohemian’s situation is still very relevant to many today. Any preconception that opera is serious is

shattered when the four friends pretend sword fight and dance with one another, chasing each

other and smashing one of Marcello’s paintings over Schaunard’s head. La Bohème is that perfect

blend of humour, tragedy, and romance, offering a bit of everything for everyone. What else worked

was the changing scenery between the first, second and third act. The audience is never in one place

for too long and Kent’s keen eye for set design and props makes sure that there is enough going on

around the talent to create a magical and immersive world. The bright colours of the costumes and

props in the second act break apart the bleak blues and cold tones of the first and third act, all the

while those very bleak colours and tones work perfectly with the unfolding tragedy in the last act.

Puccini’s score is some of his best, and while it could be argued that Madama Butterfly is the

pinnacle of his work, the story of La Bohème allows for a bit more wriggle room to play about and

have fun with the music where appropriate. Under Vasyl Vasylenko’s baton, he brings Puccini’s work


alive with the music belting deep out of the pit filling the entirety of the opera house. To return to

the point of why the cast makes this particular production stand out so well, all have that little bit of

freedom to play about and each brought their own individual voice ensuring a strong stand-out

performance each time they were on stage. The idiom “Water off a duck’s back” came to mind when

Sumbadze, Gisca and Dee in particular filled the opera house with their voices. Additionally, with

these three in particular, despite sitting in amongst 1900 seats, one felt they were receiving a

personal performance. To put it plain and simple, it was beautiful on a level which had not been fully

realised previously.

La Bohème was the first of three one night only shows at Manchester opera house, the other two

being Puccini’s Madama Butterfly and ending with Verdi’s La Traviata. With the tour going all around

the country and lasting until May, there is still plenty of time to see all three. It must be added that

despite the war in Ukraine entering its third year, the Ukrainian Opera and Ballet Theatre never fail

to disappoint and are a testament to the will of their country’s people.


Reviewer: Daryl Griffin 

Reviewed: 21/02/25

No comments:

Post a Comment