Ambroise Thomas’ operatic version of Hamlet dates from 1868, the same year as Wagner’s Meistersingers: while Wagner was creating the music of the future, his French contemporary was resolutely stuck in the present and Hamlet is a grand opera of the kind that made Paris the operatic centre of the world. All the features of the winning formula are present and correct: showy arias, mad scenes and a ballet in the third act. Thomas, remembered today solely for his biggest hit, Mignon, wanted a hit and went all out to get one.
In Jack Furness’ revival for the Buxton Opera Festival, the score is tightened up considerably - out goes the ballet (no loss at all) and in comes a somewhat hackneyed concept depicting Elsinore as a police state: each entr'acte features a member of the court doing a walk of shame ahead of an armed guard who despatches them before they reach the other end of the proscenium. The fact that Claudius is an illegitimate monarch who has seized power via crime and force is already evident in the text/libretto and hardly needs underlining in this way.
With that caveat aside, this is a worthwhile revival, strong on musical values and featuring some exciting new and new-ish talents, alongside the veteran bass Alastair Miles (a resonant and formidable Claudius). Thomas’ librettists (Michel Carre and Jules Barbier) may offer a superficial take on Shakespeare’s searching tragedy, but it is splendid vehicle for singers, abounding in gratefully written arias and set pieces that show them off to best advantage. American Gregory Feldman in the title role displayed his flexible baritone and dramatic commitment to great effect, though his stage movement was occasionally ungainly; and soprano Yewon Han’s Ophelie, though beautifully sung and with some breathtaking coloratura, would benefit from less generalised acting.
No such complaints about Allison Cook’s Gertrude, a dubious but confident and alluring piece of work who commanded the stage whenever present, the mark of a real singing actor.
The supporting roles, less numerous than in Shakespeare, were well taken with tenor Joshua Baxter standing out as Laerte and Per Bach Nissen as a sonorous Ghost of Hamlet’s Father. And orchestrally, the score - which has more than its fair share of striking moments including a long Mad Scene for Ophelie - was in the more than capable hands of the Orchestra of Opera North, conducted by Adrian Kelly. The necessarily simple but effective designs - a versatile set of steps that later transforms into a river bank - were by Sami Fendall and the atmospheric lighting design came courtesy of Jake Wiltshire.
Further performances on 16th, 20th (matinee) and 22nd July.
https://buxtonfestival.co.uk/whats-on/hamlet
Reviewer - Richard Ely
On - 12.07.2025